Pop Tarts and Chocolate Chip cookies

Homemade with Love

Sweetie Pies are homemade Pop Tarts that are made from scratch using organic ingredients. Melissa, the owner, puts love in every step of baking these delicious treats. She cuts each and every pop tart from her homemade dough and even makes the fillings and jams from scratch that fills each tart. She hopes you enjoy them just as much as she does.

Current Menu

The Sweetie Pies menu changes with the seasons. Always be on the lookout for new flavors to pop up and make your life sweet.

S’mores

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Strawberry Raspberry

Apple Pie

Blueberry Lemon Crumble

Wild Berry

Upcoming event! Sweetie Pies is popping up at Harpoon Hanna’s coffee shop, on May 19th, in New Rochelle.

Accepting Pre Orders for this event

Chocolate Chip Cookies

These homemade, soft baked chocolate chip cookies are the perfect side to your Sweetie Pies. The cookies are made in small batches and, just like the Sweetie Pies, made from scratch with organic ingredients. These cookies have a slight chewy texture on the edges with a soft center, bringing just enough sweetness to every bite.

As Seen on The Knot

Click Here ——>

Featured in Valley Table

Instagram

💕 POPPING UP at @harpoon_hannas in New Rochelle and I can’t wait! If you would like to pre order for this event, you can DM me Instagram or contact me through my website that’s linked in my bio 🥰
🔥 A busy baking weekend always has me TOASTED. Time to rest up for all all the sweet things to come for Sweetie Pies🔥
🥧 Where would you like to see Sweetie Pies pop up next?! 🥧

Sweetie Pies Minis

Sweetie Pies also come in a mini size. These minis are perfect for a dessert table at your next event or a fun bite sized treat!